Kenya Sport

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers in History

The Premier League has featured some of the finest penalty takers, known for their calmness and precision when the pressure is highest. Leading the list is Alan Shearer with 56 penalty goals, followed closely by Yaya Touré, who boasts a perfect conversion record. Other standout names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, while new talents like Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland continue this tradition of spot-kick excellence.

Scoring from the penalty spot requires more than just skill; it demands nerve and accuracy. Over the years, many players have earned their place in Premier League history due to their composure during these crucial moments. Here is the list of the top 10 best penalty takers in the league’s history, ranked by their penalty goals scored.

  • Rank: 10Player: Bukayo SakaClubs: ArsenalActive Years: 2019–PresentPenalties Scored: 12
  • Rank: 9Player: James BeattieClubs: Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke CityActive Years: 1998–2010Penalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 8Player: Callum WilsonClubs: Bournemouth, Newcastle UnitedActive Years: 2014–PresentPenalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 7Player: Erling HaalandClubs: Manchester CityActive Years: 2022–PresentPenalties Scored: 20
  • Rank: 6Player: Danny MurphyClubs: Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, FulhamActive Years: 1997–2013Penalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 5Player: Harry KaneClubs: Tottenham HotspurActive Years: 2012–2023Penalties Scored: 33
  • Rank: 4Player: Cole PalmerClubs: Manchester City, ChelseaActive Years: 2021–PresentPenalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 3Player: Matt Le TissierClubs: SouthamptonActive Years: 1992–2002Penalties Scored: 25
  • Rank: 2Player: Yaya TouréClubs: Manchester CityActive Years: 2010–2018Penalties Scored: 11
  • Rank: 1Player: Alan ShearerClubs: Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle UnitedActive Years: 1992–2006Penalties Scored: 56

Profiles of Premier League's Finest Penalty Specialists

Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)

After missing a penalty in the UEFA Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka showed immense growth and now ranks among Arsenal's top penalty takers. He boasts an impressive 92% conversion rate, scoring 12 out of 13 penalties in the Premier League across 223 appearances.

James Beattie

James Beattie made his mark as one of the most reliable penalty scorers in the Premier League era. Representing clubs like Southampton and Everton, he netted 16 penalties out of 17 attempts, maintaining a 94% success rate over 270 matches.

Callum Wilson

Callum Wilson has been a dependable figure from the penalty spot for clubs including Bournemouth and Newcastle. With 16 successful penalties in 267 appearances, his 94% conversion reflects his steady composure under pressure.

Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

Erling Haaland quickly gained a reputation for his clinical finishing, converting 20 penalties from 23 attempts. Despite three misses, his 87% conversion rate in 129 Premier League matches highlights his threat at the spot.

Danny Murphy

Although primarily a midfielder, Danny Murphy was remarkably precise from the penalty spot, scoring 18 penalties with a 95% conversion in 417 league appearances. Only once did he fail to score, and even then his team won the match.

Harry Kane

Known globally as a prolific striker, Harry Kane scored 33 penalties out of 37 attempts for Tottenham, translating to an 89% success rate. Across 320 Premier League games, his penalty-taking remains a key part of his goal-scoring arsenal.

Cole Palmer

Cole Palmer maintained a near-perfect penalty record early in his career, scoring 18 of 19 spot kicks. Now with Chelsea, he continues to show maturity and confidence in high-pressure moments during his 111 league appearances.

Matt Le Tissier

Nicknamed “Le God,” Matt Le Tissier is legendary for his penalty prowess, missing only once in 25 attempts. His 96% conversion rate helped him score 24 penalties and a total of 101 goals for Southampton over 270 matches.

Yaya Touré

Yaya Touré remains unique for never missing a Premier League penalty, scoring all 11 he took for Manchester City. His composed style and powerful shots made him one of the most feared penalty takers during his tenure from 2010 to 2018.

Alan Shearer

Leading the chart, Alan Shearer scored a staggering 56 penalties but also missed over ten, resulting in an 84% conversion rate. Despite this, his role as the Premier League’s all-time top scorer with 260 goals cements his legacy as a dominant spot-kick specialist.

Premier League Penalty Takers FAQ

  • Who is the Premier League's greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer tops the list as the greatest penalty scorer in Premier League history.
  • Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers?Yes, he ranks 7th on this all-time list.
  • Who are the top 3 Premier League penalty takers?The top three are Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier.
  • Where does Erling Haaland stand among EPL penalty takers?He is placed 7th among the greatest penalty takers in Premier League history.

Related Articles